Day 213: Adam Goodes: You’re All Missing The Point

Loathe as I am to add another voice to the cacophany of commentary on the issue of Adam Goodes, frankly I’ve had all I can stands and I can’t stands no more. More than anything, I just feel like most people are entirely missing the point. So I’m weighing in, readers beware.

I cannot count the number of people I have seen in the last week – on my news feed, in comments sections, on talkback radio, in opinion pieces – the sheer number of people I’ve seen fiercely defending their inalienable right to boo Adam Goodes. A staggering number of people who have said some variation of the following:

“I’m not booing Goodes because I’m racist, I’m booing because he’s a flog/grubby/on the other team”
“Plenty of footy players get booed, he needs to harden up”
He’s the racist one because x, y and z”
I’m not racist, but x, y and z”
“He deserves it for acting like a dickhead”

And so on. If you are one of those people, or if you have liked posts or comments made by those people, or are just thinking about becoming one of those people, let me give you some free advice.

Shut. The fuck. Up.

I mean it. Shut the fuck up. Just stop talking. This is NOT about your right to boo football players. This is NOT about whether or not you are personally a racist. In fact this issue actually has nothing to do with you, beyond the horrible message that you are sending with your boorish, entitled, selfish responses.

I repeat: this is not about you. So shut the fuck up.

Let’s recap what you’ve missed on previous episodes of The Adam Goodes Saga. In 2013, he was racially taunted by a girl in the crowd and pointed her out to security. In 2014, he was awarded the Australian of the Year, for his work for the Indigenous community and work fighting against racism. Since then he has spoken publicly about his desire to amend the Constitution to reflect the place of Indigenous Australia in our country. Two months ago, Goodes celebrated AFL Indigenous Round by performing an Indigenous-style dance after scoring a goal. Just last week, he was booed so vociferously by Eagles fans that Lewis Jetta performed a similar dance in solidarity, creating this week’s media shitstorm. And now Goodes, one of the great players of the modern game, has been so beleaguered by weeks, months and years of booing, racial vilification and public backlash to these events that he can’t even face running out for his team this weekend. Goodes has literally been driven out of AFL this week by his detractors.

And all you have to say on the subject is “I’m not booing him because he’s black!” …?

Me, me, me! Do whatever you want to this man, but don’t blame me, whatever you do! I’M not a racist!

Maybe, just maybe, if we have a very prominent, very successful Indigenous man, a man who plies his trade in the great Australian pastime: sport, and still can’t get through a footy season without experiencing racial abuse in some form or another…instead of finding ever more creative ways to make this about yourselves, and instead of finding ever more creative ways to victim-shame, maybe you could just stop talking and actually listen to what he has to say.

When Goodes was racially taunted by a crowd member who happened to be a 13 year old girl, did you listen to him explain why he was “gutted” to hear that coming from a child, but that he didn’t blame her and wanted her to receive support, privacy from the media and to be educated about what her words mean? Or did you just call him “sensitive” for “overreacting”? Did you talk, or did you listen?

When Goodes won the Australian of the Year for his work on Indigenous issues and racism, and used the platform of his acceptance speech to speak about – shock horror – Indigenous issues and racism, did you take the time to watch his speech, or read the text, to see what he had to say? Or did you listen to talkback radio and then complain that he shouldn’t have “bagged” Australia when it gave him an honour? Did you talk, or listen?

When Goodes spoke out about the Australian Constitution, about the inherent racism in certain sections of a hundred year old document, and about wanting an amendment to recognise Indigenous and Torres Strait Islander Australians, did you actually listen to his arguments? Did you take a look at the Constitution and read the offending sections to see if he was right? Or did you whinge about Adam Goodes being “ungrateful” or even “racist” towards Australia again? Did you talk, or listen?

When Adam Goodes decided to celebrate AFL Indigenous Round (Indigenous Round!!) by performing a war cry from his culture, did you watch his expression of pride in the heat of the moment, or listen to his later explanation that he was taking the opportunity of Indigenous Round (In-di-ge-nous Round!!!) to represent his heritage upon scoring (just like Greg Inglis and many others do on a weekly basis in all sports), or did you criticise him for “threatening” Carlton supporters with an imaginary spear? Or perhaps you just started booing him every time he touched the ball for being a “flog”, and then defended to the death your right to act like an asshat when others condemned systematic and sustained abuse of an outspoken Indigenous figure for what it is: racism.

But I’M not a racist! I can boo whoever I want! Just try and stop me! Me, me, ME!

When an Indigenous leader like Adam Goodes speaks out about facing racism in this country, don’t bag him. Don’t even talk. Just listen. For that matter, when an Indigenous person speaks out about facing racism in this country, don’t talk. Listen. You might learn something.

For instance, you might learn that even though you’re not a racist, even though you happened to boo Goodes because you think he staged for that free, that abuse has now taken on a racial character, whether you like it or not. It makes the victim of the abuse feel racially vilified by the community, whether you like it or not. We as white people cannot dictate to an Indigenous person when they can or cannot feel racially abused. What we can do is stop perpetrating the behaviour that makes them feel that way. And eliminating that shit from the game is FAR more important than your need to boo a Swans player. I’m sorry, it just is. This is not your problem. I repeat: this is not YOUR problem. It is his problem, and he wants it to stop.

So seriously, for the love of God, just shut the fuck up.


7 thoughts on “Day 213: Adam Goodes: You’re All Missing The Point

  1. Darwinite says:

    What you think white people cant be victims of racial abuse?
    Your a complete moron and that one statement proves it. You have made your own argument null & void.
    So I think it is you who needs to Shut The Fuck Up.


    • Where did I say that white people can’t be victims of racial abuse?

      If you read the whole sentence, I said that in this context the white majority can’t tell an Indigenous man when he can or can’t feel racially abused. Goodes has been a victim of sustained abuse by a largely white Australian supporter base and public, and always off the back of him speaking out against racism or racist behaviour. He has been called an “ape” and condemned for performing an Indigenous dance. He feels racially vilified.
      And so many idiots (naturally white people in this case) feel like they have the right to say “It’s not racist..” and then tell Goodes to get over it or “toughen up princess”, and then feel perfectly entitled to keep booing and perpetrating racist behaviour. Because they’ve decided that it’s not racist.

      The white majority in this country has no right to tell a victim of racism that they aren’t experiencing racism. It’s victim shaming, plain and simple.


  2. ADAM Goodes insists he is unperturbed by the incessant booing he cops from opposition crowds during games, choosing to view it as a mark of respect.

    Goodes is choosing to believe that is the motivation behind the crowd reaction.

    “It hasn’t been difficult,” he told reporters on Wednesday when asked about the booing. “It’s not something that I’m not used to.

    “There’s been many a time being booed at football grounds.

    “Sometimes it’s a mark of respect, that the opposition fans don’t want you to play well, and every time you get the football.

    “It doesn’t bother me to be honest.

    “It’s one of those things where if I pay too much attention to what the crowd’s doing, then I’m not really playing my role on the field.

    “We’re just worried about getting out there and winning games, wherever they are, and since I’ve been back this year we’ve only lost two games.

    “It’s been a pretty good streak for us as a football club, but me individually as well.”

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Frank says:

    The fact you wrote “….years of booing” shows how little you know. He was not booed last year at all, as I, unlike you attend AFL matches regularly, including Swans matches and this is a 2015 problem. Seriously, do some proper research or just Shut. The Fuck. Up.

    Liked by 1 person

    • That’s my bad, my overblown run-on sentence makes it look like that’s what I’m saying when I’m not. It wasn’t meant to read “years of booing” but “weeks, months and years of booing, racial vilification and public backlash…”

      I know the booing is a recent issue. My point is that the issue of Goodes’ treatment by certain people, in general, is a long-standing one. It not only concerns the last couple weeks of booing but goes back years, starting in a mainstream sense in 2013 with the “ape” controversy, but I’m also sure it started many years before that for Goodes himself, who would have copped racist abuse from crowds for as long as he’s been playing football.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s